How does the Ford F-150 Lightning actually compare to the 2023 GMC Hummer?

For that matter, why is the Lightning ranked #1 at Car and Driver for electric trucks? How did it become the first electric truck to take Motor Trend’s most coveted prize? The GMC Hummer electric truck certainly doesn’t seem like a pushover.

This 2023 Ford F-150 Lightning vs GMC Hummer comparison will look for answers to these questions and provide a framework for your own comparisons between electric trucks today.

Heavyweights and Horsepower

Hummers are heavyweights in any context, weighing more than light duty and many heavy duty trucks. In fact, the new GMC Hummer EV pickup weighs some 2,000 pounds more than the 2023 Ford Lightning. In its April 2022 review, CNN cites the Hummer truck’s weight as a possible factor in its safety, particularly with regard to other vehicles on the road.

Simple math would indicate that the Hummer must produce much more power to move the same load as the Lightning. You can probably best see the difference if you look at towing capacity. The Lightning can tow as much or more as the Hummer. It can also move a heavier payload.

So, although the Hummer can claim higher horsepower and torque, it cannot claim greater utility than the 2023 Ford Lightning, especially with its extended range battery. In fact, as some critics have noted, small Ford Mavericks can handle a bigger payload than GMC Hummer electric pickup trucks.

Cargo Bed and Truck Frunk

Both trucks have a frunk in the spot where an engine would be in a gas-powered truck. Yet despite its overall size, the Hummer frunk is almost 3 cubic feet smaller than the Lightning’s storage compartment.

Then there’s the cargo bed. The Hummer bed measures only 5 feet while the Lightning bed measures 5.5 feet. To make up for the lack of space, Hummers have higher bed sides, but that comes with the downside that it is harder to reach into the bed when you need to.

In the end, the Ford bed can hold a standard 58.4 cubic feet of materials. Hummer electric truck beds hold only 36.7 cubic feet. With about 20 cubic feet extra space, the Ford is definitely more capable.

Cabin Size and Comfort Level

Considering the enormous price difference between the Lightning and Hummer electric trucks, you would think that the Hummer would be the most comfortable. That’s a matter of opinion but here’s what is clear.

While it is true that the Hummer has more room for the two front row occupants, it is obvious that the Ford is providing much more space for the second row. Consumers paying the luxury price tag are not thrilled with leatherette seating.

Despite improvements, Hummer EV truck critics are still commenting that the seat padding is too firm. Drivers are frustrated with the Hummer’s windshield. The short length makes it harder to see.

Phoenix AZ passengers aren’t too thrilled with the roof panels. There’s nothing to protect from glare, and that would be a dealbreaker on one of our summer days. Lastly, US News and World Report notes that the Hummer ride is too loud, especially given its price tag.

Cabin Features

At the most affordable price, it’s only natural that the Ford Lightning isn’t as fancy as the GMC Hummer. However, there’s no denying that the Lightning is giving more value for the money.

High tech, the Ford has touchscreen infotainment features and offers even more on higher trims. The digital instrument panel is 12 inches, and the touchscreens are either 12 inches or 15.5-in portrait-style. It has the entire suite crash avoidance features, too. Ford shoppers can get exclusive technologies such as Pro Backup Assist and a Smart Hitch.

Ford’s higher trim levels add leather, something you’d expect on the Hummer that currently isn’t offered. Dual power adjustable seats can also have individual air cooling, a favorite in Phoenix AZ. You could pack the Lightning with everything the GMC has to offer and still not spend as much money.

Cost to Own

In terms of cost to own, it is significant that the GMC Hummer electric truck is rated for only 49 MPGe in combined driving. The Lightning earns 68 or 70 MPGe combined.

That should result in considerable savings over the life of the vehicle. No one wants to overpay for fuel! As for electric range, Fords earn 240 or 320 miles depending on the battery. In addition, Ford provides complimentary charging with the Blue Oval Charge Network and Electrify America.

Then there’s the Hummer price tag. It is well over $100,000 now. Lightnings are available for as little as $58,000. The most luxurious Lightning still saves you more than $10,000 over the initial cost of the Hummer.

Now that you know more, head to your Rodeo Ford dealer to see what the Lightning can do for you. You may order the Ford electric truck through our website or give us a call to discuss your options.